Friday, November 15, 2019

Why did Taylor Marshall Chicken Out in Questioning Bp. Schneider on the Bellarmine teaching on Heretical Popes Ceasing to be Pope?

- Updated March 2, 2020

On November 15, 2019, Taylor Marshall said "Bellarmine says when anyone is a manifest heretic even the pope he ceases to be a member of the Church and they can no longer hold their office "

Why did Marshall chicken out in questioning Bishop Athanasius Schneider on Doctor of the Church St. Robert Bellarmine's teaching on heretic popes ceasing to be pope in his podcast with Bishop Athanasius Schneider on the 28th of February?

On November 15, Marshall and the contributing editor of The American Spectator George Neumayr who is a best-selling author and former editor of the Catholic World Report apparently called on the Catholic cardinals to convene in order to judge if Francis is a "manifest heretic" which could mean he "self vacated the Chair of St. Peter" and is no longer the pope.

In Marshall's popular YouTube channel the two declare what "should happen":

"[Neumayr said Doctor of the Church St.] Robert Bellarmine said members of the Church have the right and duty to resist a bad pope... It is the cardinals who have the power to confront the pope and say do you actually support the teachings of the Church. If you don't then you self vacated the Chair of St. Peter and we can move to elect a new pope... "

"... [Marshall said] Bellermine says when anyone is a manifest heretic even the pope he ceases to be a member of the Church and they can no longer hold their office... It seems to me that that would require a ecclesiastical decree... You would have to have cardinals make this decree... "

"... [Neumayr said] It's a case of declaration. They are simply declaring what Francis himself has done through his actions and statements. He would in fact have self vacated the Chair of St. Peter then the cardinals would simply come in and declare that happened and move to fill the Chair with a new pope. We are at that stage when I know that should happen."
(Dr. Taylor Marshall YouTube Channel, "Why are USA Bishops Tone-Deaf & Promoting Liberal Policies? w George Neumayr," 1:02:05 to 1:06:55)

Pray an Our Father now for the restoration of the Church and for the laity to demand that the cardinals convene an imperfect council to judge if Francis is a manifest heretic.

7 comments:

  1. It seems as if Marshall might actually reading your blog since, until now, he has seemed to take a posture of 'papalotry' that would preclude saying anything that would echo Cardinal Bellarmine.

    ReplyDelete
  2. "... [Marshall said] Bell[a]rmine says when ANYONE is a manifest heretic even the pope THEY cease to be a member of the Church and THEY can no longer hold their office..."

    The fact that even bona fide Catholic trads are using the "singular 'they'" shows just how insidious this Marxist gender-weapon is.

    ReplyDelete
  3. We must spread the word on our false Pope. I just posted this article on FB.

    ReplyDelete
  4. Read where Innocent 3rd was a layman when he was elected Pope. Perhaps that might be the road to travel in the current state of Vatican affairs.

    ReplyDelete
  5. marshall and Schneider are shameless flip floppers for their careers. No faith, only desire for praise and money...

    ReplyDelete
  6. Francis/Bergoglio is the Occupant of the Chair.

    I wouldn't stand to close to this Claimant of the See of Peter. There's already been lightning strikes.

    ReplyDelete