Thursday, March 12, 2020

Michael Matt: "[T]wo Catholic Churches now... they can't both be Right"

Why can't Remnant editor Michael Matt say this, today, of the Francis Church?

In 2000, Matt in "We Resist You To The Face" wrote:

"The terrifying reality of the present situation is that there are, for all practical purposes, two Catholic Churches now... Rudimentary apologetics tells us they both can't be right and true."
(We Resist You To The Face, Page 101, Copyright 2000 © by Tradition In Action, Inc.)

2 comments:

Jack said...

I disagree with Michael Matt's premise. When you're an ideological thinker who takes an ideological stand, of course you're going to see the world in terms of us vs. them. Apart from the minority of ideologically charged liberals and ideologically charged traditionalists trying fiercely to provoke and condemn one another, there is the mainstream of the Church that goes bustling on through history like always.

Fred Martinez said...

Jack and Jill and Francis are not "ideologically charged... trying to provoke and condemn one another, there is the mainstream of the Church" that supports Communion for adulterers.